idiots guide — 1 thorough investigation

idiots guide, missing the apostrophe, is a publishing genre and also a way of life. there is a man at the bar who explains all of them to anyone within a stool’s radius. apartment ceilings, in my opinion, count as the first chapter of any guide worth reading.

the genre, properly named, is the complete idiot’s guide to — to anything. to wine, to taxes, to mediumship, to the new testament, to playing the harmonica, to whatever the publisher’s acquisitions team thought a normal person needed help with in 1993. there are, last i checked one of forty-seven tabs, more than four hundred titles. four hundred. that’s not a series. that’s a quiet civilization.

i, as a self-identifying member of the target demographic, would like to file a few notes from inside the tent. the canonical investigation of the word idiot is already on this site for anyone who needs the longer version. this post is shorter, and it concerns the genre.

writing this from the desk on the second-from-the-window side. carla is at the q3 review on the third floor. i have, by the optimistic count, the rest of the morning before her notes start arriving in chronologic batches.

idiots guide, the genre’s mission

the founding promise of the genre, as i understand it from the back covers of the four copies i have owned and the seven i have flipped through in bookstores while pretending to be waiting for someone: this is the book for people who do not already know. that’s it. that’s the entire pitch. the rest is execution.

most reference books, by contrast, are written for people who already know about half the subject and want to know the other half. they assume vocabulary. they assume context. they assume you have the kind of life where you’ve already absorbed, by osmosis, the fact that there are different kinds of vinegar. an idiots guide assumes none of this. an idiots guide assumes you walked into the bookstore yesterday because someone said you should learn about wine, and now here you are, and the wine section of the bookstore is, in itself, intimidating.

that, for the record, is a real service. a real one. you can be condescended to, charmingly, for two hundred and fifty pages, and walk out knowing the difference between a chardonnay and a chablis, which are, against all odds, the same grape. i learned that from a copy of the complete idiot’s guide to wine i bought in 2018 and have, since, used mainly as a coaster. the book is now permanently scarred with a ring from a glass of the very wine it was trying to teach me about. there’s a metaphor in there. i won’t insist on it.

the format that promised everything to no one

the format itself is, to my taste, the genre’s secret weapon. every book has the same skeleton. the same fonts. the same little icons in the margins — a lightbulb for “tip”, an exclamation point for “watch out”, a magnifying glass for “fun fact”. you open any one of them, on any subject, and the book is already half-familiar. you know where to look for the warnings. you know where to look for the side notes. the layout, in this sense, is doing some of the work of teaching you how to read it.

this is, i would argue, the publishing equivalent of a chain restaurant. you walk in, and the menu is already in your head. you know there’s a soup of the day. you know the burger comes with fries. you know the dessert section will have a cheesecake. is it the best cheesecake on earth. it is not. is it the cheesecake you wanted at this exact moment. yes. that, in essence, is the idiots guide model. dependable carbohydrates of the mind.

i could be more snobby about this. people are. people who own one wall of unread hardcovers tend to be. but i’m not, on this one, going to be snobby, because the book that taught me how to file my own taxes for the first time was, no kidding, the complete idiot’s guide to doing your taxes, edition 2007. i still have it. i still file my taxes wrong. but i file them on time, which is, by adult standards, a win, and the book is the reason.

the stefan-type at the bar who owns ten of them

now, on a bar stool somewhere — this is, technically, MC1 of the canon, but you don’t need to know that to follow along — sits stefan. stefan is not actually named stefan. stefan has, however, every other quality of a stefan: the slim glasses, the opinions about croissants, the apartment where every book is in alphabetical order by the author’s middle name. stefan, when i mentioned the genre over a beer, said he owns ten of them.

stefan owns: the complete idiot’s guide to wine (which he has, of course, read), to mediumship (which he claims to have read for “research”), to the harmonica (he does not own a harmonica), to chess openings, to home brewing, to spanish verbs, to investing in your forties, to the new testament, to grant writing, and to organizing a small wedding. stefan is single. stefan was, briefly, in 2019, planning a small wedding. the wedding did not happen. the book remained.

stefan’s collection, as a body of work, tells me something. it tells me that the genre is aspirational scaffolding. you do not buy the complete idiot’s guide to mediumship because you intend to talk to the dead next thursday. you buy it because you want, in the back of your mind, to be the kind of person who could, if pressed, explain mediumship at a dinner party. the book is not a manual. the book is a future identity, paid in advance, in paperback. that’s, frankly, more dignified than what most aspirational purchases are. (the third yoga mat under my couch is also an aspirational purchase. the third yoga mat has not made me a yogi. but it has, by sitting there, occasionally reminded me that i was, once, the kind of person who thought yoga might happen.)

the apartment where i shelve mine, badly

my own collection of idiots guides lives, currently, on the top shelf of a bookcase in my apartment, behind a row of second priority books, which are themselves behind a row of first priority books, which i have also not read. the system is structural. it would take an afternoon to dig out the wine guide. it would take a small structural engineering survey to retrieve the taxes guide. the books are, in this sense, already serving their secondary purpose, which is to be there.

the seventh microwave hums in the kitchen, indifferent. the seventh microwave has, in its short life, witnessed three of my attempts to learn things from these books. the wine attempt ended when i microwaved a glass of bad red to “open up the flavor”, per a tip i invented and then attributed, falsely, to the book. the wine did not, for the record, open up. the microwave, also for the record, smelled faintly of merlot for a week. dave, when i told him, laughed for nine minutes. i timed it, which is, in itself, a hobby i have developed over the last two years. dave, who is the only acceptable laugh-counter in my life, is also the keeper of the list, by which i mean the list of microwaves i have killed, written on a napkin in his glove compartment.

the third yoga mat, also relevant here, came home one evening because i had, that morning, read three pages of the complete idiot’s guide to yoga and decided i was a yoga person now. that was 2023. the mat has not been unrolled. the book is somewhere in the second-priority shelf. the version of me that bought both is gone, and i am, in his memory, still pretending.

hot dog is a sandwich, also relevant somehow

i would now like to take, in the proud tradition of these guides, a brief detour. one of the things the genre does, which i admire, is acknowledge that learning happens sideways. you sit down to learn about wine, and the book tells you a small story about a chef in lyon. the story has nothing to do with grapes. the story is, however, the bit you remember. that is teaching.

so, in that spirit, i would like to remind the reader that a hot dog IS a sandwich. fight me. it is. two pieces of bread, however joined, with filling between them. that is a sandwich. the bread can be a single folded piece. the filling can be tubular. these are not disqualifications. these are, as the genre would put it, sub-categories. the complete idiot’s guide to the new testament has whole chapters on sub-categories. the principle holds.

i bring this up because the question what is a sandwich is, structurally, the same question as what is an idiots guide. it is a question about category boundaries. the book on wine includes a section on cheese. the book on cheese, somewhere, mentions wine. the boundaries are fuzzy on purpose. the genre is honest about that. so am i, on the sandwich question. so are you, if you’re being honest.

the case for the genre’s persistence

the genre has, against several waves of cultural change, persisted. youtube did not kill it. wikipedia did not kill it. the algorithm — the diffuse, ambient antagonist of all of internet — has not killed it. you can still walk into any bookstore in 2026 and find at least three of these books, with the orange spine, on a shelf near the front. that, in publishing terms, is a small miracle. most genres, given thirty years and the internet, do not survive.

my theory, for what it’s worth — and you can write this down, i’ll wait — is that the genre survives because the format itself is the comfort. you do not, when you buy the complete idiot’s guide to investing in your forties, expect to actually invest in your forties. you expect, rather, to hold a paperback that promises you could, if pressed, do that. the book is a small contract with the future. it is, in the same way the third yoga mat is a contract with a future yoga practice, mostly a way of buying, for fifteen dollars, the temporary feeling of being the kind of person who has plans. that is not nothing. that is, if you ask me, what a lot of consumer purchases are. the genre is just unusually honest about it.

this is not, i should say, the only kinship in the neighborhood. i’d point you, briefly, sideways: the word moron, in its own register, runs in the same lane as idiot — the moron-themed corner of this site is the moron pillar across the hall, where similar accusations get filed under a different surname. moron and idiot are, etymologically, cousins. they go to different bars. they wave, awkwardly, across the street.

verdict, the genre is honest, also useful, occasionally

the verdict, after seven hundred words and one detour about hot dogs, is this: the idiots guide genre is, by my reckoning, honest. it tells you what you’re getting. it gives you a chapter on wine, a chapter on cheese, a small icon in the margin to warn you off the bad pairing, and an index in the back where you can find the term you forgot. it is, structurally, better-organized than my apartment. it is, in many cases, better-organized than the lectures i sat through at university, and the books cost less than a textbook by a factor of about thirty.

i do not always read them. i am, in fact, mostly a non-reader of the books i own. but the genre has earned, in my opinion, the small honor of staying on the shelf, in the apartment, where i can see it. that is the contract i have with most of my belongings: be here. wait. one day i may use you. probably i won’t. but you are an option, and the option is, itself, a kind of life.

for related reading, the literary corner of this site has, separately, a longer note on the dostoevsky novel from 1869 in its 2003 essayistic frame for anyone who wants a heavier book on the same word, and a shorter one on elif batuman’s idiot for anyone who wants a lighter one. neither is in the idiots guide format. both are about, broadly, being one. the genre’s reach, you’ll find, is wider than its publisher.

and, if you want a moving picture rather than a paperback, the closest thing to an idiots guide on television is, in my opinion, the man-on-camera reclamation of the word, idiot at work series — itself the subject of a separate investigation on this site. it is not a book. it is, however, a beginner’s manual to a particular kind of tuesday. the icons are different. the lessons are the same.

FOUR HUNDRED TITLES. ONE FORMAT. ONE CIVILIZATION.

carla rounded the corner with two folders. two folders is more meeting than one. screen down. tab closed. i’m calling it a wrap on the morning’s work, which is, technically, this post.

↑