signs of a narcissist boyfriend — 1 thorough investigation

a boyfriend with these signs is the boyfriend you describe to a friend over a salad and the friend says, gently, that you should maybe call your sister. i called my sister. my sister had thoughts. her thoughts are heavily quoted in this piece.

i drafted most of this on a clipboard in a doctor’s office, which i’ll explain, and the rest at my desk on a thursday at 12:51pm while carla sat through the annual planning meeting on the third floor. that gives me, by the count i keep running, the rest of the afternoon, which is more than i deserve and less than i would like.

the word boyfriend is doing heavy lifting here. boyfriend is provisional. boyfriend is a job title with a probation period. you can fire him by saying “i think we should” and not finishing the sentence. that part matters. the signs of a narcissist boyfriend are not signs of a narcissist husband, which is a different essay i won’t be writing because i am, to be specific, not married, possibly never married, and certainly not asking.

writing this from my desk. carla is upstairs in the planning meeting. i have, technically, the rest of the afternoon. let’s go.

before i get to the list — and there is a list, with eight numbered items, because the assignment said listicle and i, on this thursday, am compliant — i want to say that the pattern of gaslighting in close relationships is the engine under most of these signs. the boyfriend is the chassis. the engine is the same. you can swap the chassis and keep the engine and most people do, repeatedly, for years.

signs of a narcissist boyfriend, the disclaimer

i am not a clinician. i am a man with a clipboard in a doctor’s office, which is a different qualification entirely. nothing here is a diagnosis. nothing here will hold up in a court, a therapist’s office, or a brunch with his mother. this is a list compiled by someone who has been wrong before and who suspects, on a thursday afternoon, that he is now slightly less wrong.

i’ll add: the signs of a narcissist boyfriend are not the same as the signs of a difficult boyfriend, a boring boyfriend, a boyfriend who chews loudly, or a boyfriend who has, against the wishes of his entire household, opinions about the dishwasher. those are different categories. those are sometimes just men. the narcissist boyfriend is a pattern, not a personality flaw. patterns are what i’m here for.

if you’ve watched the 1944 film called gaslight you have a working illustration of the engine i mentioned. ingrid bergman, a townhouse, a husband dimming the lamps and telling her she’s mistaken about the lamps. the lamps were dimming. she was right. it took two hours, in black and white, for the audience to be sure. it takes longer, in color, on a thursday, in real life.

the doctors office where i drafted this on a clipboard

i have been at the doctor’s office for, by my watch, an hour and twenty. they gave me a clipboard with a form on it. the form has eleven questions. i answered four. i started writing this on the back. the receptionist has not asked me to stop and i have not asked her to start, so we are operating in the gray zone where productive things happen on stolen surfaces.

the doctor’s office is also, importantly, where my sister called. she was in her car. she had ten minutes. she said, in the tone she uses when she’s already decided, “i’m going to say this once and then i want you to think about it for a week.” she said it. i thought about it for, conservatively, six minutes. then i started this list.

my sister’s thesis, which i’m not going to attribute by name because the sister-of-an-anonymous-blogger is also anonymous by extension, is that a narcissist boyfriend is recognizable not by what he does but by what he refuses to acknowledge. the doing is loud. the refusing is quiet. the refusing is the tell.

items 1 to 4, the boyfriend-grade ones

here are the first four. these are the ones friends will spot first. these are also the ones you, the person inside the relationship, will defend the longest, often using the phrase “he’s just like that”, which is, my sister said, the most expensive sentence in english.

1. he corrects your stories in front of other people. not the facts that matter. the small ones. “it was tuesday, not wednesday.” the room goes quiet for half a second. you laugh it off. that half second is the data.
2. his feelings are weather; yours are a logistics problem. when he is upset, the room rearranges. when you are upset, he asks how long this is going to take. the calendar matters more than the cause. you start to schedule your own crying.
3. he has an ex who is, somehow, both crazy and still texting. the ex is always crazy. the ex is always still texting. nobody who has ever been described to me as crazy has been crazy. they have, occasionally, been right.
4. he has read one book about himself and quotes it at you. sometimes the book is a personality test. sometimes it’s an enneagram. sometimes it’s a podcast he listened to once. “i’m a four wing three” is not a personality. it’s a license plate.

items 5 to 8, the boyfriend-grade-too ones

these next four are quieter. these are the ones that make you, in year two, stand at the kitchen counter at 11pm with a glass of water and ask yourself whether you’ve become a difficult person. you haven’t. you’ve become an observant person. there’s a difference. it’s the difference between a witness and a defendant.

5. the chore equity is a chart he keeps in his head. he can list, with timestamps, every time he loaded the dishwasher in the last quarter. he cannot, mysteriously, list a single time you did. the chart is a one-way mirror. you are on the wrong side.
6. your friends are downgrading. first they stop asking him along. then they stop mentioning him. then they stop asking how things are. friends know. it is their power. it cannot be defeated.
7. his apologies are conditional sentences. “i’m sorry you felt that way”, “i’m sorry if i came across as”, “i’m sorry but”. an apology with a comma in it is a press release. a real apology is one sentence and ends in a period.
8. he gets generous when you start to leave. the flowers arrive. the trip is booked. the apology widens to fit a holiday. this is not love returning. this is a campaign in its closing week. ironing is a class war i refuse to fight, my mother used to say at the kitchen table, and i think about that a lot now, because the narcissist boyfriend is, structurally, an ironing problem — he wants the surface flat and he wants you to do the flattening.

EIGHT SIGNS. ONE BOYFRIEND. PROVISIONAL.

closing pulpit, the boyfriend is provisional, the signs are recurring

the boyfriend is provisional. the signs are not. you can change the boyfriend. you can swap the chassis. the engine, as i said at the top, often comes along for the ride if you don’t, at some point, name it and refuse to drive it.

the seventh microwave is on my counter at home, humming in a way it didn’t last week. the third yoga mat is still under the couch from 2023, possibly evolving. i mention these because they are mine, and they are stupid, and the difference between a bad object and a bad boyfriend is that the object cannot, when you throw it out, accuse you of overreacting.

the appliance is on its way. (this section funded, in the metaphorical sense, by the next microwave.) the boyfriend is, with any luck, already gone.

the receptionist just called my name. i’m wrapping up. carla is, by my watch, still in the planning meeting. some meetings are weather. some are logistics problems. this one, i think, is the second.

↑